Was the Judge That Dismissed the Case?

The best book I read in there was maybe like Atlas Shrugged. We were reading primarily fiction. What was the case to begin with? I don't even know. So we beat him, you know, with a, with a jury, acquitted on all charges in Oregon and then we went down to Nevada and she ultimately dismissed it. And then the, of course, the US attorneys appealed the decision. It went to the Ninth Circuit and the Ninth Circuit unanimously agreed that, that the case was egregious. And they, they dismissed it without, without, without.