Unraveling the Mystery of Mary's Death

The chapter explores various theories surrounding the murder case of Mary, discussing potential connections to a tavern owner, an abortionist's trial, and a sexually motivated crime. Speculations about a botched abortion and a young physician's involvement are analyzed, alongside the impact of misinformation spread by tabloids and Edgar Allan Poe's fictionalized version of Mary's story. The hosts reflect on the challenges of finding evidence from the 1840s and highlight the importance of experience in understanding the crime and bringing in a coroner for further investigation.