The Story of a Woman Who Kills Her Husband

Melanie's phone conversations revealed she was also in regular contact with a man named James Finn. The two had attended nursing school together in the mid-90s, and although the nature of their current relationship was unclear, their conversations were often flirtatious. Dr Miller admitted his infatuation with Melanie had blinded him to skepticism. He initially denied having romantic feelings for her, but when he was informed Melanie had purchased a gun less than a week before Bill's murder, he cracked. On June 2, 2005, a little over a year since Bill's body part surfaced, Melanie McGuire was formally charged with first degree murder.