This chapter examines the intricate relationship between empathy and moral decision-making, revealing how empathy can lead individuals to make less just choices by favoring those with whom they feel a connection. It discusses the potential pitfalls of empathy, including its ability to perpetuate inequality and tribalism, and advocates for a combination of emotional responses and rational thought to address social dilemmas. The chapter ultimately calls for a redefinition of moral frameworks, such as 'metamorality', to better align altruistic actions with broader societal well-being.