Scaling AI Beyond Experimentation

Vic Malhotra, former McKinsey senior partner and coauthor of CEO Excellence and A CEO for All Seasons, examines the strategic pressures that now define the CEO role: a “30- to 40-year tech revolution,” intensifying geopolitics, shifting consumer behavior, and demographic change. As he notes, “every business at some level is a tech business,” and this multipolar, fast-changing environment places a premium on leaders who can “thread the needle” between paradoxes, short-term delivery versus long-term reinvention, legacy versus disruption, and analysis versus decisiveness.

The conversation connects these macrotrends to practical leadership mechanics, how to set direction, allocate scarce resources, and design institutions that can learn, adapt, and scale without losing their core.

Key strategic insights and takeaways

Set an audacious, persistent north star. “The very best leaders set bold, some might say audacious, aspirations early in their tenure,” Malhotra explains. Through downturns and market noise, they “persevere” and repeat a few priorities “until the organization internalizes them.” Consistency, not novelty, creates credibility and followership.

Treat resource allocation as a hard choice. “Capital, expense, and talent, it’s a zero-sum game,” he recalls from his interview with Jamie Dimon. Great CEOs “starve something” to fund their boldest bets and resist spreading resources “like peanut butter.”

Make culture operational and selective. Effective leaders focus on one or two levers that reinforce strategy, Satya Nadella’s emphasis on a growth mindset at Microsoft being a prime example. They design rituals, incentives, and role modeling that embed new behavior.

Build a star team, not a team of stars. As one CEO told Malhotra, “This is not about a team of stars, it’s about a star team.” Complementary strengths, mutual accountability, and candor matter more than individual brilliance.

Institutionalize continuous learning and reinvention. Exceptional leaders avoid the “sophomore slump.” They systematize learning—internally by seeking dissent and externally by “looking around corners.” “You can never be complacent,” Jamie Dimon told him. “You’ve got to keep pushing forward.”

Operate as a technology-native company. “Every company is a tech company,” Malhotra insists. Technology must be business-led, embedded in cross-functional product teams, and scaled deliberately beyond experimentation, especially in AI.

Anticipate nonmarket shocks. Leading teams now run geopolitical and demographic scenarios “to understand how the company might have to pivot.” This preparedness extends to smaller firms “thrust into geopolitics” for the first time.

Distinguish between experimentation and bet-the-company decisions. Leaders should allow “rapid, cheap failure” to learn quickly, but apply exhaustive risk management to the few “truly consequential, bet-the-company” decisions. 

Here are some free gifts for you:

Overall Approach Used in Well-Managed Strategy Studies free download: www.firmsconsulting.com/OverallApproach

McKinsey & BCG winning resume free download: www.firmsconsulting.com/resumepdf

Get Exclusive Episode 1 Access of How to Build a Consulting Practice: www.firmsconsulting.com/build

Enjoying this episode? Get access to sample advanced training episodes here: www.firmsconsulting.com/promo