Generic LLM Judges vs Bespoke Reward Models

In this deep dive with Kyle Corbitt, co-founder and CEO of OpenPipe (recently acquired by CoreWeave), we explore the evolution of fine-tuning in the age of AI agents and the critical shift from supervised fine-tuning to reinforcement learning. Kyle shares his journey from leading YC's Startup School to building OpenPipe, initially focused on distilling expensive GPT-4 workflows into smaller, cheaper models before pivoting to RL-based agent training as frontier model prices plummeted. The conversation reveals why 90% of AI projects remain stuck in proof-of-concept purgatory - not due to capability limitations, but reliability issues that Kyle believes can be solved through continuous learning from real-world experience. He discusses the breakthrough of RULER (Relative Universal Reinforcement Learning Elicited Rewards), which uses LLMs as judges to rank agent behaviors relatively rather than absolutely, making RL training accessible without complex reward engineering. Kyle candidly assesses the challenges of building realistic training environments for agents, explaining why GRPO (despite its advantages) may be a dead end due to its requirement for perfectly reproducible parallel rollouts. He shares insights on why LoRAs remain underrated for production deployments, why GEPA and prompt optimization haven't lived up to the hype in his testing, and why the hardest part of deploying agents isn't the AI - it's sandboxing real-world systems with all their bugs and edge cases intact. The discussion also covers OpenPipe's acquisition by CoreWeave, the launch of their serverless reinforcement learning platform, and Kyle's vision for a future where every deployed agent continuously learns from production experience. He predicts that solving the reliability problem through continuous RL could unlock 10x more AI inference demand from projects currently stuck in development, fundamentally changing how we think about agent deployment and maintenance.

Key Topics:

• The rise and fall of fine-tuning as a business model

• Why 90% of AI projects never reach production

• RULER: Making RL accessible through relative ranking

• The environment problem: Why sandboxing is harder than training

• GRPO vs PPO and the future of RL algorithms

• LoRAs: The underrated deployment optimization

• Why GEPA and prompt optimization disappointed in practice

• Building world models as synthetic training environments

• The $500B Stargate bet and OpenAI's potential crypto play

• Continuous learning as the path to reliable agents

References

https://www.linkedin.com/in/kcorbitt/

• • Aug 2023  https://openpipe.ai/blog/from-prompts-to-models 

  • DEC 2023 https://openpipe.ai/blog/mistral-7b-fine-tune-optimized

  • JAN 2024 https://openpipe.ai/blog/s-lora

  • MAY 2024 https://openpipe.ai/blog/the-ten-commandments-of-fine-tuning-in-prod  

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-hYqt8M9u_M

• Oct 2024 https://openpipe.ai/blog/announcing-dpo-support 

• AIE NYC 2025 Finetuning 500m agents https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zM9RYqCcioM&t=919s

• AIEWF 2025 How to train your agent (ART-E) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gEDl9C8s_-4&t=216s

• SEPT 2025 ACQUISTION https://openpipe.ai/blog/openpipe-coreweave 

• W&B Serverless RL https://openpipe.ai/blog/serverless-rl?refresh=1760042248153