The Hider is somebody who is against the pirates. But deep down, they do not want the pirates there. They want the pirates gone, but they're rationale. I think their rational and emotional rationale is if I make myself a target, if I leave by planting a flag on a lifeboat, I'm going to be a target. That's the sort of strategic rationale. And then the story they are telling themselves is if I can outweight them. If I hide long enough, they will leave and I will get my ship back. Whether or not they have really looked at it, like, and analyzed that story. David, how realistic is that as a narrative? It's
“Founding friend” David French returns to tackle the tough question that every Republican of good faith should be asking. They explain why this particular question of “Should I stay or should I go?” is highly relevant for everyone, regardless of political affiliation. The conversation explores the ways that political calculations inescapably are spiritual in nature, and the two have a fun time unpacking this reality via the “pirate ship” metaphor. Listeners will especially be helped by how David and Curtis explain the three main options - Leave, Stand, or Hide - facing anyone who feels caught in a deeply dysfunctional institution.
For those who want to connect with other “Leavers,” share your thoughts with others on the Good Faith “lifeboat” in the comments section for this episode (you only need to become a member by subscribing here - it’s free).
For those who want to make a “Stand” for the soul of the evangelical church, learn more about The After Party project.
For those interested in the mindset of “Hiders, read Anne Applebaum’s excellent analysis of the psychological rationalization practiced within the GOP (The Atlantic).