Media Influence vs. Elected Office

On today’s Chuck ToddCast, Chuck breaks down why Marjorie Taylor Greene’s resignation is less an isolated drama and more a warning sign that Trump’s once-tight MAGA coalition is splintering. From Speaker Mike Johnson taking cues directly from Trump to a wave of looming GOP retirements, Chuck explains why Republicans may face a bleak 2026. He also digs into Trump’s mixed economic record, his unexpected openness to extending ACA subsidies, and the widening rift between Republicans over Ukraine, where a new peace proposal appears to reflect more of Kyiv’s asks than Moscow’s. With Europe carrying most of the burden and Trump seen abroad as a lame duck, Chuck argues that MAGA may be reaching the end of its political shelf life as fractures emerge across every major wing of the coalition.

Sports & political commentator Clay Travis joins Chuck Todd for a candid conversation that spans the worlds of politics, sports, and media. They explore the shifting boundaries between culture and athletics, the pressure of serving a politically-charged audience, and what Clay learned from stepping into Rush Limbaugh’s former timeslot. Clay discusses the importance of distinguishing fact from opinion, the challenges of modern political incentives, and how law school shaped his worldview. The two also talk about the realities of online hostility, audience expectations, and Clay’s belief that influence in media can outweigh influence in elected office.

The episode also digs deep into college football: conference realignment, the CFP committee’s biases, southern schools’ growing appeal, and how cultural and political trends—from Gaza protests to regional identity—shape the sport’s landscape. Clay and Chuck debate how to fix the playoff system, what makes college football uniquely personal for fans, and which major sports league Nashville could attract next. Clay closes by sharing the presidential contenders he wishes would run in 2028 and why treating political opponents like rival sports fans could be a healthier way forward.

Finally, Chuck gives his ToddCast Top 5 Thanksgiving Dishes, previews a pivotal weekend in college football and answers listeners’ questions in the “Ask Chuck” segment.

Go to https://getsoul.com & enter code TODDCAST for 30% off your first order.

Thank you Wildgrain for sponsoring. Visit http://wildgrain.com/TODDCAST and use the code "TODDCAST" at checkout to receive $30 off your first box PLUS free Croissants for life! 

Got injured in an accident? You could be one click away from a claim worth millions. Just visit https://www.forthepeople.com/TODDCAST to start your claim now with Morgan & Morgan without leaving your couch. Remember, it's free unless you win!

Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/chuck. Application times may vary. Rates may vary.

Timeline:

(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)

00:00 Chuck Todd’s introduction

03:30 MTG’s resignation a sign of Trump’s coalition fracturing

04:15 MAGA is more likely to continue fracturing rather than galvanize

05:00 Republicans probably hoping for impeachment if Dems take house

06:15 Johnson keeping the house out of session was a huge mistake

07:45 Mike Johnson isn’t operating on his own, Trump dictates to him

09:15 Trump’s agenda has made the economy worse

11:00 Other Republican lawmakers signaling they may resign early

12:15 Holidays are the season of early retirement decisions

13:00 Likely we see 10 or more Republican retirements by end of January

14:45 Donald Trump signals willingness to extend ACA subsidies

17:00 Lame duck president and Dem majority will discourage GOP reelect bids

18:30 Congress has been cut out of governing, makes the job suck

20:00 Ukraine peace plan details have been all over the map

20:45 New peace deal contains more of Ukraine’s considerations

21:15 Trump just wants a deal, doesn’t care about the details

22:30 To his credit, Trump has people on his team supporting Ukraine

25:00 Skeptical that new deal will be well received by the Russians

26:00 Putin knows Trump is a lame duck and will play the long game

27:30 Europe provides most support to Ukraine, Trump has less leverage

29:15 Split between Rubio & Vance wings over Russia and Ukraine 

30:30 We are seeing fractures throughout Trump’s coalition

31:30 MAGA may be approaching the end of its shelf life

36:30  Clay Travis joins the Chuck ToddCast

38:00  GW’s near win over the Fab Five 

40:00  Thoughts on McAfee interviewing Trump on ESPN?

40:45  If the president wants to do your show, you do it

42:00  Are you a sports guy that does politics or a politics guy that does sports

42:45  Taking over Rush Limbaugh’s timeslot for Premiere Radio

44:00  Balancing sports content vs. politics content

45:30  Sports used to be separate from culture, now they’re intertwined

47:15  Having the audience you want vs. the one that you have

48:00  Clay’s audience is people who voted Trump, love football, hated Covid masks

49:00  Not letting your audience be your editor

51:30  Learning not to care too much what people think about you

52:45  Everybody is mean on the internet, you have to have thick skin

54:30  Going to law school was the best decision Clay ever made

57:00  We need better distinction between fact & opinion in politics

57:45  Politics doesn’t attract the best & brightest due to low pay

58:30  Too many people in politics just want to be famous

59:45  Nick Saban could have been great at anything, including politics

01:02:00  Non SEC & Big Ten schools get no notice from the CFP committee

01:04:30  It’ll be interesting to see which big conference ACC programs try to join

01:06:00  Southern schools have become a huge draw for northern students

01:07:00  Gaza protests have affected student recruitment at some schools

01:08:30  Lane Kiffin will be the hottest name in the college coaching market

01:09:45  CFP committee cherry picking results, not acknowledging ACC

01:10:45  College football is the sport we’re always arguing about

01:11:30  Playoff selections need to be non subjective, needs a new system

01:12:45  Dems focus on what America did wrong, R’s focus on what went right

01:14:30  Quality wins should matter more than quality losses

01:15:15  People feel a closer personal connection to college football compared to NFL

01:16:00  Best way to reconfigure the college football playoff?

01:17:45  College football should start in August prior to NFL kicking off

01:19:30  What’s the next major sport coming to Nashville? MLB

01:20:30  There are more NHL, NBA and NFL teams in SEC footprint than MLB

01:22:00  Sports is unique in that the competition IS the business

01:24:00  Four people Clay would like to see run for president in 2028

01:26:30  Pitchforks are coming for corporate America & business candidates

01:28:15  Any interest in running for office?

01:29:15  Can have more influence and impact in media than in politics

01:30:15  Paul Finnebaum mulling run for office

01:31:45  We’d be better off if we treated political opponents like opposing fans

01:34:00  Nashville is always viewed as the “new _____”

01:36:00  Chuck’s thoughts on interview with Clay Travis

01:36:45  Thanksgiving is where we try to be the best version of ourselves

01:37:45  ToddCast Top 5 Dishes For Thanksgiving Dinner

01:38:00  #1 A meat that is an alternative to roasted turkey

01:38:45  #2 Macaroni and cheese casserole, not out of the box

01:39:30  #3 Sweet potato casserole with marshmallows

01:40:30  #4 Green bean mushroom casserole

01:41:30  #5 Leftover pumpkin pie w/coffee the next morning

01:43:00  College football preview

01:55:15  Ask Chuck

01:55:30  Will AI take CEO jobs? Does it present a threat to capitalism?

01:59:30  Has Trump given license to racists & misogynists to be more overt?

02:03:00  Is it possible that teams will play down against Notre Dame?

02:06:30  Thoughts on Qatari air force facility being built in Idaho

02:08:00  Paradox between presidential immunity vs “take care” clause?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.