
How Israel is responding to the ICJ ruling
The Listening Post
Introduction
Exploring the recent interim ruling by the ICJ on the genocide case brought against Israel by South Africa, discussing the ordered provisional measures and the challenges in enforcing them.
00:00
Transcript
Play full episode
Transcript
Episode notes
Speaker 2
We begin in the Hague where just this past Friday, the UN's top court delivered an interim ruling on the case of genocide brought against Israel by South Africa. The ICJ ordered so-called provisional measures to protect Palestinians from genocidal acts in Gaza. However, it stopped short of calling for a ceasefire. This was a highly anticipated ruling. It was broadcast around the world. The ICJ's rulings are legally binding. However, they can be difficult to enforce, especially while Israel enjoys the protection of the United States at the UN Security Council, where the U.S. has the power of veto. However, there is no doubt that the ruling did not go Israel's way. The court has found a plausible risk that genocide is occurring or could occur. And that will be difficult for the Israeli government to shrug off try as it might. Now this news coming when it did on a Friday afternoon, very late in our production schedule, means that we haven't had time to fully examine the legal implications. But Tarak Nafa has been following the coverage and he joins me now. What are the initial repercussions that you're seeing out there?
Speaker 3
Well, a lot was at stake here, Richard, not just for Palestinians who are being killed and starved by Israel en masse, but also for the credibility of the international legal order. This may be the most politically divisive case ever brought before the Hague. Could and should the court have gone further in explicitly ordering a ceasefire? Many will say yes, absolutely. But does the ICJ's decision effectively amount to the same thing? That's the interpretation of South Africa's foreign minister.
Speaker 7
I believe that in exercising the order, there would have to be a ceasefire without it. The order doesn't actually
Speaker 3
work.
Part 1: What does the ICJ ruling mean for Israel?
Judgement day at the International Court of Justice. The court has ruled the people of Gaza must be protected from genocidal acts carried out by Israel.
Richard Gizbert is joined by producer Tariq Nafi to discuss the impact this ruling could have on how the media discuss the war in Gaza.
Part 2: Mohammed el-Kurd on Palestinian resistance
Writer and journalist Mohammed el-Kurd in a video essay on Palestinian resistance and the Western media’s warped coverage of Palestine.
Contributor:
Mohammed el-Kurd - Writer and journalist
Part 3: India: Temple opening or election campaign kickoff?
A long-anticipated – and deeply contentious - consecration of a Hindu temple in India this past week featured Prime Minister Narendra Modi front and centre.
The country's mainstream media enthusiastically played along, giving Modi valuable airtime in what is an election year.
Contributors:
Apoorvanand - Professor, Delhi University
Seema Chishti - Editor, The Wire
Pamela Philipose - Author, Media's Shifting Terrain
Sreemoy Talukdar - Deputy executive editor, Firstpost
Judgement day at the International Court of Justice. The court has ruled the people of Gaza must be protected from genocidal acts carried out by Israel.
Richard Gizbert is joined by producer Tariq Nafi to discuss the impact this ruling could have on how the media discuss the war in Gaza.
Part 2: Mohammed el-Kurd on Palestinian resistance
Writer and journalist Mohammed el-Kurd in a video essay on Palestinian resistance and the Western media’s warped coverage of Palestine.
Contributor:
Mohammed el-Kurd - Writer and journalist
Part 3: India: Temple opening or election campaign kickoff?
A long-anticipated – and deeply contentious - consecration of a Hindu temple in India this past week featured Prime Minister Narendra Modi front and centre.
The country's mainstream media enthusiastically played along, giving Modi valuable airtime in what is an election year.
Contributors:
Apoorvanand - Professor, Delhi University
Seema Chishti - Editor, The Wire
Pamela Philipose - Author, Media's Shifting Terrain
Sreemoy Talukdar - Deputy executive editor, Firstpost