Raising Prices and Building a Successful Agency

Would you like access to our advanced agency training for FREE? https://www.agencymastery360.com/training

Have you mastered the art of always obtaining the client's budget? Are you ready to elevate your pricing strategy and focus on quality over quantity? There are certain things that will only get easier with experience. Yet, all agency owners should be aware of how crucial it is to adapt your pricing model and client acquisition strategy to ensure long-term success. Today’s featured guest started his agency in 1997 and has learned a lot about the milestones that changed his agency’s growth path, the things that had to change along the way, and why continuous improvement and evolving capabilities are the best way to adapt to a changing market. Tune in to learn more about the challenges and triumphs of building a successful agency, the pricing strategies that have kept his agency afloat, how he is navigating a recent acquisition, and the improvements yet to be made to cement his agency’s brand.

James Pietruszynski is the CEO of SoulSight, a full-service brand design agency that collaborates with partners to deliver visionary work with a soulful approachability. With 27 years of experience, James shares insights into the evolution of his agency. He reflects on the milestones that have defined his growth journey, the lessons about understanding the value you bring to clients to grow beyond a certain point, what he’s learned from a recent acquisition, and more.

In this episode, we’ll discuss:

• The factors that drove his agency acquisition.

• Strategies to create sustained agency success.

• Why you should be raising prices instead of taking on new clients.

Subscribe

Apple | Spotify | iHeart Radio

Sponsors and Resources

Wix: Today's episode of the Smart Agency Masterclass is sponsored by Wix, an intuitive way to design exceptional sites and a smart addition to your agency’s toolkit. With this flexible tool, your team will be able to take on any project at any scale and focus on the work that matters the most. Check out wixstudio.com and break free from growth bottlenecks.

Continuous Improvement, Acquisitions, and Evolving Capabilities as the Pillars of Enduring Success

Currently running an agency that is well over the eight-figure mark, James looks back on starting in 1997 and the many milestones that mark this journey, measured primarily through the caliber of clients and strength of brand relationships. One of their first big moments was winning major client Molson Coors, which marked their entry into the realm of Fortune 100 brands.

This initial breakthrough catalyzed the agency's expansion as they continued to grow with a focus on client retention, with some client partnerships spanning two decades, a testament to their commitment to excellence.

As a team, they set their long-term goals through a three-year planning process, where they anticipate potential challenges and identify opportunities for growth. They evaluate what they know and make predictable assumptions of what may happen and then focus on things that need to change and improve to be more efficient.

At the heart of their continued success lies a commitment to evolution and adaptation. James regularly assesses internal capabilities and actively seeks opportunities for enhancement, whether through restructuring creative teams, streamlining operations, or pursuing strategic acquisitions. A recent example is their acquisition of a wellness-focused brand design agency—a strategic move that not only expands their service portfolio but also strengthens their ability to meet clients' changing needs.

Chemistry and Retention as Factors Driving an Agency’s Acquisition Strategy

When acquiring another agency, always take the time to ensure that the values, mission, and vision of both organizations align. For James, chemistry and retention were the most important elements he looked for in an ideal partner, not only for a successful acquisition process but also to foster long-term relationships that drive sustainable growth.

If this chemistry extends beyond just the leadership and through the entire organization, it will influence how teams interact and collaborate post-acquisition, ensuring a smoother transition and integration. As to the second element, Jim was looking for an agency demonstrating five to seven years of client retention.

When it came time to negotiate the purchase, he favored an earn-out model, which has proven consistently effective in his experience. For the most part, he found that the agency partners and leadership team had no problem sticking around after the purchase to help grow the agency so he worked with the leadership team to structure a deal that included both upfront cash and performance-based incentives to ensure they remained motivated to grow the business.

Although it’s not for everyone, for James this model not only protects the acquiring agency’s investment but also fosters a sense of shared purpose and commitment among the teams involved. It reinforces the idea that both parties have a stake in the ongoing success of the agency, thereby enhancing retention on both sides.

Leaving Behind RFPs to Create Sustained Agency Success

Although RFPs were more credible twenty years ago and their first big break with Molson Coors did come as the result of a well-put-together RFP, James believes currently most of their business comes organically through relationships.

By this point in his agency’s growth the team doesn’t participate in many RFPs a year. Agencies nowadays dare to say no to most RFPs, which can serve as a jump-off point to sell a foot-in-the-door strategy and stand out from anybody that is just wasting time preparing that RFP. With this, you’ll already be on their radar and they’ll be much more likely to pay for your services again.

On the other hand, he does acknowledge his agency could be a brand name by now had they focused more on their own marketing to build their reputation. As the work poured in, client work would always take priority, leaving them less and less time to even plan their own marketing strategy.

The challenge of balancing client work with internal marketing efforts is a double-edged sword. Focusing on client needs is no doubt essential for immediate business success; however, neglecting self-promotion can create bottlenecks in growth and limit the agency's visibility in a competitive market.

Jim is now more focused on putting a renewed effort into the agency’s marketing, starting with its website. This will always be a challenge for agency owners but try to not fall into the trap of becoming so client-centric that they lose sight of their own brand identity.

The Art of the Budget Conversation: How to Set Realistic Expectations

Jim prefers to charge hourly rates, which in his view reflects a commitment to transparency and accountability in pricing. Hourly billing can provide clients with a clearer understanding of the time and resources invested in their projects, reinforcing the value delivered. However, it also necessitates that agencies effectively communicate the rationale behind their rates and the expected outcomes, so clients feel confident in their investment.

Obtaining a clear understanding of the client's budget is a critical, yet often overlooked, part of the process. When agencies inquire about budgets upfront, they are frequently met with reluctance, which may stem from the client's desire to gauge the agency's pricing structure without revealing their own financial limitations. In these situations, ask for a budgetary range, even if the client is hesitant to provide specifics. This at least gives the agency a general sense of the client's spending intentions, allowing them to tailor their proposals accordingly. Start with the biggest number “Do you want to spend $1 milion? 100K? 10K?”

Alternatively, present them a new option of buying a strategy session where you help them figure out their goals and gain more clarity. This way, you’ll be positioning yourself as an authority with this foot-on-the-door and they’ll be more likely to hire you once they’ve already established a client relationship.

If they can’t commit to do any of this then they might not be the best client for you, as they lack a basic understanding of what they’re willing to invest on the project. Establishing a budgetary framework early on is essential for setting realistic expectations and ensuring that both the agency and the client are aligned in their goals.

Strategies to Build a Sustainable Agency Business in a Post-Pandemic Landscape

In the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, James has faced the challenge of agencies lowballing their prices far below what they should be charging. This has at times cost his agency business opportunities, with clients citing his agency's prices as too expensive. However, James recognizes that the right clients will always be willing to pay for the value his agency provides.

In fact, losing business because of price more often than not can be a sign that you’re not properly explaining your process. Work on explaining the results and success you can help bring clients and you’ll get them excited to pay your prices because they’ll recognize the value you’ll be bringing to their business.

Along with the price increases, growing your agency will also lead to taking on fewer clients than you did in previous years. There’s a misconception that agencies must double their client roster to achieve significant revenue increases. Instead, focus on acquiring fewer clients but at higher price points. You’ll get to this point by concentrating your efforts on that your agency truly excels at to more effectively showcase your value.

Other than that, he has been focusing on streamlining processes, making informed decisions quickly, and building strong relationships with clients who can be brand champions within client organizations. This way, agencies can gain insights into pricing thresholds and client expectations so they can better serve their clients while also justifying their pricing structures.

Do You Want to Transform Your Agency from a Liability to an Asset?

Looking to dig deeper into your agency's potential? Check out our Agency Blueprint. Designed for agency owners like you, our Agency Blueprint helps you uncover growth opportunities, tackle obstacles, and craft a customized blueprint for your agency's success.