Top Professor Condemns AGI Development: “It’s Frankly Evil” — Geoffrey Miller
Doom Debates
Navigating AI in Academia
This chapter explores a professor's experiences balancing teaching, research, and service in the age of AI. It addresses the challenges of ensuring academic integrity amidst rising AI technologies, emphasizing the importance of genuine learning and original thought. Additionally, the discussion highlights educators' emotional responses to AI's impact on education and the potential erosion of critical skills among students.
Geoffrey Miller is an evolutionary psychologist at the University of New Mexico, bestselling author, and one of the world's leading experts on signaling theory and human sexual selection. His book "Mate" was hugely influential for me personally during my dating years, so I was thrilled to finally get him on the show.
In this episode, Geoffrey drops a bombshell 50% P(Doom) assessment, coming from someone who wrote foundational papers on neural networks and genetic algorithms back in the '90s before pivoting to study human mating behavior for 30 years.
What makes Geoffrey's doom perspective unique is that he thinks both inner and outer alignment might be unsolvable in principle, ever. He's also surprisingly bearish on AI's current value, arguing it hasn't been net positive for society yet despite the $14 billion in OpenAI revenue.
We cover his fascinating intellectual journey from early AI researcher to pickup artist advisor to AI doomer, why Asperger's people make better psychology researchers, the polyamory scene in rationalist circles, and his surprisingly optimistic take on cooperating with China. Geoffrey brings a deeply humanist perspective. He genuinely loves human civilization as it is and sees no reason to rush toward our potential replacement.
* 00:00:00 - Introducing Prof. Geoffrey Miller
* 00:01:46 - Geoffrey’s intellectual career arc: AI → evolutionary psychology → back to AI
* 00:03:43 - Signaling theory as the main theme driving his research
* 00:05:04 - Why evolutionary psychology is legitimate science, not just speculation
* 00:08:18 - Being a professor in the AI age and making courses "AI-proof"
* 00:09:12 - Getting tenure in 2008 and using academic freedom responsibly
* 00:11:01 - Student cheating epidemic with AI tools, going "fully medieval"
* 00:13:28 - Should professors use AI for grading? (Geoffrey says no, would be unethical)
* 00:23:06 - Coming out as Aspie and neurodiversity in academia
* 00:29:15 - What is sex and its role in evolution (error correction vs. variation)
* 00:34:06 - Sexual selection as an evolutionary "supercharger"
* 00:37:25 - Dating advice, pickup artistry, and evolutionary psychology insights
* 00:45:04 - Polyamory: Geoffrey’s experience and the rationalist connection
* 00:50:96 - Why rationalists tend to be poly vs. Chesterton's fence on monogamy
* 00:54:07 - The "primal" lifestyle and evolutionary medicine
* 00:56:59 - How Iain M. Banks' Culture novels shaped Geoffrey’s AI thinking
* 01:05:26 - What’s Your P(Doom)™
* 01:08:04 - Main doom scenario: AI arms race leading to unaligned ASI
* 01:14:10 - Bad actors problem: antinatalists, religious extremists, eco-alarmists
* 01:21:13 - Inner vs. outer alignment - both may be unsolvable in principle
* 01:23:56 - "What's the hurry?" - Why rush when alignment might take millennia?
* 01:28:17 - Disagreement on whether AI has been net positive so far
* 01:35:13 - Why AI won't magically solve longevity or other major problems
* 01:37:56 - Unemployment doom and loss of human autonomy
* 01:40:13 - Cosmic perspective: We could be "the baddies" spreading unaligned AI
* 01:44:93 - "Humanity is doing incredibly well" - no need for Hail Mary AI
* 01:49:01 - Why ASI might be bad at solving alignment (lacks human cultural wisdom)
* 01:52:06 - China cooperation: "Whoever builds ASI first loses"
* 01:55:19 - Liron’s Outro
Show Notes
Links
* Geoffrey’s University of New Mexico Faculty Page
* Designing Neural Networks using Genetic Algorithms - His most cited paper
* Geoffrey’s Effective Altruism Forum Posts
Books by Geoffrey Miller
* Mate: Become the Man Women Want (2015) - Co-authored with Tucker Max
* The Mating Mind: How Sexual Choice Shaped the Evolution of Human Nature (2000)
* Virtue Signaling: Essays on Darwinian Politics and Free Speech (2019)
* Spent: Sex, Evolution, and Consumer Behavior (2009)
Related Doom Debates Episodes
* Liam Robins on College in the AGI Era - Student perspective on AI cheating
* Liron Reacts to Steven Pinker on AI Risk - Critiquing Pinker's AI optimism
* Steven Byrnes on Brain-Like AGI - Upcoming episode on human brain architecture
---
Doom Debates’ Mission is to raise mainstream awareness of imminent extinction from AGI and build the social infrastructure for high-quality debate.
Support the mission by subscribing to my Substack at DoomDebates.com and to youtube.com/@DoomDebates
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit lironshapira.substack.com
The AI-powered Podcast Player
