The Experimenting Society
Book •
The Experimenting Society is presented as an argument for bringing experimental and quasi-experimental research into public policy.
Peter Katzenstein cites its author, Campbell, as warning that academics cannot substitute their judgment for that of policymakers.
Instead, researchers should provide evidence and analytical assistance while elected leaders determine what matters politically.
The reference supports Katzenstein’s broader distinction between knowledge and judgment under uncertainty.
It underscores his view that policy decisions cannot be reduced entirely to models, measurements, or expert predictions.
Peter Katzenstein cites its author, Campbell, as warning that academics cannot substitute their judgment for that of policymakers.
Instead, researchers should provide evidence and analytical assistance while elected leaders determine what matters politically.
The reference supports Katzenstein’s broader distinction between knowledge and judgment under uncertainty.
It underscores his view that policy decisions cannot be reduced entirely to models, measurements, or expert predictions.
Mentioned by
Mentioned in 0 episodes
Mentioned by 

as Donald Campbell’s argument that research can assist policymakers without replacing their judgment.


Peter Katzenstein

Entanglements in World Politics: The Power of Uncertainty with Peter J. Katzenstein (Cambridge UP, 2026)
Mentioned by 

while discussing experimental research, policymaking, and the limits of academic advice.


Peter Katzenstein

Entanglements in World Politics: The Power of Uncertainty with Peter J. Katzenstein (Cambridge UP, 2026)



